Mini Review: Initiated, Memoir of a Witch

Hello, book friends! A quick note to say that our power is still off (we’re entering day three). My laptop has a bit of a charge and I can use a hotspot to stick to posting for a sense of normalcy, I probably won’t be super active in terms of reading and interacting. I hope to catch up on things as soon as our power is back on, estimated to happen late tomorrow night.

We sure are having an adventure in rural living. Don’t worry, our house has stayed relatively warm and Azula is now in her sweatshirt. We have relatives near by we can stay with if things get dire, so we’re safe but inconvenienced. Anyway, on to the promised mini-review!

Format read: Hardcover

Rating: 2.5 stars (rounded up to 3 on Goodreads)

When I happened upon the beautiful teal cover of Initiated: Memoir of a Witch, I was drawn to the book immediately. It is truly a cover that speaks to my witchy soul, and the thought of reading a memoir explicitly about someone’s witchcraft journey excited me. 

Unfortunately, this book wasn’t at all what I expected it to be. It took me a long time to finish it, though I did feel determined to do so. In today’s mini-review, I’m going to attempt to articulate why this didn’t work for me. 

When I hear the word “initiated,” I expect to hear the story of how a woman discovered her magic and embraced it. This book doesn’t quite do that in the way I expected. Rather, it is a story of Amanda Yates Garcia’s “journey through the underworld,” her metaphorical reading of how the trauma of her young life ultimately led her to witchcraft. 

This book is darker and more difficult than I expected. It also does some experimentation with truth and metaphor, such that I sometimes struggled to follow the author’s narrative and understand what was literally true and what was emotionally true. 

I’m all for a bit of experimentation in memoir, but I do like to be able to tell when it’s happening. Here, it was a bit difficult to parse what the author believed to be literally happening and where she used archetypes and witchcraft to speak emotional truths. 

For a book that is the memoir of a witch, not much about the practice of witchcraft appears in the pages except in bits and pieces. This makes sense as the author is looking at how her life led her to embracing the ancestral magic she forgot, but I still would’ve liked a bit more detail about how she stepped back into her magic. In this version, we hop and skip around in time and don’t ever really see how we go from a traumatized young woman to the Oracle of Los Angeles. 

That’s not to say there isn’t some interesting writing happening here, and at times the book is quite captiviating. I can’t say I’m not glad I finished it, because it was a unique sort of read. It wasn’t quite what I hoped it would be, but I’m sure it would resonate with some readers who enjoy a good memoir about coming of age and reclaiming your life after trauma. 


3 thoughts on “Mini Review: Initiated, Memoir of a Witch

  1. I hope your power is restored soon! So glad you’re not cold or in dire circumstances, but it’s a real challenge to live more than a few hours without power.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s